Building Kombrig's 1/700 Destroyer
Valerian Kuibyshev in its 1943 fit |
|
by Vladimir Yakubov |
History In 1911 Imperial
Russian Navy laid down a large destroyer that proved to be as revolutionary
for WWI as US Fletcher class DDs were for WWII. In 1913 that destroyer
- named Novik - was commissioned. It was the fastest and most heavily
armed destroyer in the world. Novik was armed with four very powerful
4"/60 and eight 18" torpedo tubes and reached 37 knots on trials - making it
the fastest warship in the world at the time. Russian navy immediately
realized the excellent warship that they had on their hands and between 1912
and 1915 no less than 53 destroyers based on Novik were laid down.
They were not copies of Novik but were laid down in seven series that had
slight differences in dimensions, speed and armament. On of these
destroyers was a Series III Novik type, also known as Gavriil class, destroyer Kapitan Kern.
The ship displaced 1260 tons, was armed with four 4"/60 guns and three
triple 18" torpedo tubes and had a top speed of 32 knots. It was laid
down in St.Petersburg at the Putilov factory on 21 November 1913. Work
progressed pretty fast and the ship was launched in August 1915.
However Russia lagged in the manufacture of high speed turbines which were
often ordered overseas (some of which were ordered in Germany and actually
went on to power German half-copies of Novik class - V97 class) and with the
war many of then were delayed or not delivered at all, which caused the work
on many of the new ships to stop. Unfortunately the same fate
awaited Kapitan Kern. The work on it stopped and it was abandoned in
the fitting out basin. The ship got new life when in 1925 it was inspected
by the new Soviet government and found that the hull was sound and could be
finished to fill out the ranks of growing Soviet Navy. At the same
time the ship got its new name Valerian Kuibyshev - a political leader of
the Red army and one the important ministers in the Soviet Government. The ship was
finally commissioned in 1927. In 1933 it was transferred to the newly
created Northern Fleet and was periodically refitted. The ship started
WWII in the North and was very active from the first day - laying mines and
shelling advancing German troops. It was very active in escorting
convoys but due to its short range could not escort them all the way to
England (its range was only 1720nm at 16 knots), so most of the escort
missions involved taking over escort from the allied warship close to Murmansk. During one such mission in February 1942 a close explosion
of the mine damaged the ship, so that it spent next three months being
repaired. In June 1942 it took part in the fruitless rescue attempts
of convoy PQ-17 (which lost 23 ships out of 36 that set out for Murmansk).
In November 1942 Kuibyshev took part in the rescue of the crew of destroyer Sokrushitel'nyi which broke up in the storm. In terrible weather
176 people were rescued by Kuibyshev. In August - September 1943 the ship was
refitted with sonar and and extra AA guns. By that time the ship's
displacement reached 2020 tons, while max speed dropped to 28 knots.
Anti-Aircraft armament was increased to two 45mm/68 21-KM guns, two 37mm
70-K guns, two 20mm Oerlikons and three 12.7mm DShK machine guns. The
ship had very active war escorting both Soviet and Allied convoys until
almost the last day of the war. During the war the ship shot down
several German aircraft and attacked several German U-boats, through now
were confirmed sunk by it. The veteran ship continued to serve until 1955
when it was converted to a test ship and was scrapped in 1956. |
The KitOne of the latest
Kombrig releases, WWII Kuibyshev has 42 excellent resin parts. As
customary with Kombrig the small details are nearly flawless. Guns,
ship's boats, bridges and ventilators are flawlessly cast with very little
flash and no air bubbles. Unfortunately the hull is pretty badly
disproportioned for such a distinctive ship. On the right you can see
the comparison of the hulls Kuibyshev's WWI sister ship Azard and Kuibyshev
as corrected to fit the plans (which were actually provided with the kit,
which surprised me since it show that they had correct plans). There
were two main problems with hull. While the length was correct, the
problem is that it was 1.5mm too short in front of the forward
superstructure and 1.5mm to long at the stern. The second problem is
that the hull is 2mm too wide in the middle. It starts from the step
behind the forecastle and goes all the way to the stern. While 2mm
would not be very noticeable on a battleship, on a slim long hull of a
destroyer it is very visible. Overall the kit is OK, since the hull
problems while annoying are relatively easy to solve for anyone with
moderate skills. |
|
click images
to enlarge |
|
|
Construction |
|
|
|
|
The Hull
As pointed out above the hull was the biggest problem in the kit.
To solve the profile problems I cut off the bow just in front of the forward
superstructure and inserted about 1.5mm thick piece of styrene in between
the pieces. This gave the nose the correct length and made the
superstructure seem more proportional with the rest of the hull. Now
however the ship was about 1.5mm too long. Fortunately that length
came straight out of the stern and after shaving it the profile of the ship
was just right. That left us the problem of extra width. In real
life the ship was 9.34m wide, however the kit scales out to 10.5m wide,
which on a long slim hull of a destroyer is really noticeable. To cure
this problem, I took a Dremel tool and shaved about 1mm from either side of
the ship starting from the end of the forecastle to the stern of the ship.
After sanding the hull and using the putty to fill in the dents left by
Dremel, the hull was nearly ready to go. The long thin superstructure
sides in the middle of the hull were sanded down during the thinning of the
hull, but were built up again using 1mm styrene glued from the inside.
The forward gun platform was about 1mm to wide so I shaved a little off both
sides. The bridge was cast integral with the conning tower, but was a
bit too small, plus in real life it was open from the back, so I took it off
and decided to scratchbuild it. It this point I added smoke stacks and
PE doors as I usually do before painting and was ready to paint. I chose
to do the ship as it appeared in mid 1943, since I had a relatively clear
photo of the ship in that camouflage scheme and I really liked it. At
the time, the ship was camouflaged in dark grey and white (or very light
gray) splinter camouflage. I saw a similar undated photo of the
opposite side of the ship carrying identical camouflage, so I decided to
paint both sides of the ship with nearly identical camouflage. I first
painted the deck and the sides dark grey and then drew the camouflage scheme
on a profile of the ship scaled to the need size and using that drawing cut
out the necessary patterns from masking tape. Once all the pattern was
masked I sprayed it with white, but I deliberately didn't completely clean
the airbrush before doing it, so the white came out looking dingy, uneven
and dull. After necessary touchups I covered the ship with
Black-It-Out a water soluble ink-like liquid to do the shading. After
it dried I wiped it off with Q-tip and stiff brush leaving it in the
recesses to add texture. As a final step I dry-brushed the hull and
touched up where necessary and was finally ready to add small details. |
|
|
|
Photo from "Entsiklopedia Sovetskih Nadvodnyh Korabley
1941-45" (Encyclopedia of Soviet Surface ships 1941-45) by A.V. Platonov |
|
|
DetailsFirst thing I did was to
add the bridges as I always do. I decided to scratchbuild the forward
bridge since the kit bridge was too small and the bridge was open from the
back. The bridge sides were made from canvas covered railings, so to
simulate it I installed the railings and then I filled the spaces between
them with thinned down white glue. Once it dried it settled in between
the railings forming a textured surface that looks just like railings with
sagging canvas over them. It is slightly exaggerated, but looks OK
once drybrushed. Then to make the bridge windows I took piece 1/350
scale ladder and bent it to shape and glued on top of the railing. I
scratchbuilt the bridge instruments and the roof. All of the bridges
had solid splinter shields around them, but in real life the bridges were
framed with canvas covered railings, so I cut off the splinter shielding and
clued the railings and used the same while glue to simulate the canvas.
In the amidships superstructure there were solid splinter shields that were
present on the real ship, but since the hull was narrowed the boat deck also
had to be cut down, which destroyed the shields. I scratchbuilt them
using Alps printer paper, which has the consistency of plastic and is about
the same thickness as 0.005 plastic, but is stronger and easier to work
with. I use it whenever I need to simulate photo etch. In
building the model I used WEM and Tom's Modelworks photo etch. Armament Next big step
was the armament. While the ship was old, it was literally covered
with weapons. The kit included four very nicely molded 4" guns one 3"
AA gun and four 37mm AA gun. The 3" gun would be useful if the ship
would be built in its 1927 to 1940 fit, but it was removed in 1941.
Kombrig's instructions say that in 1944 the ship carried four 37mm guns, and
it is very possible that it was true (the information on Noviks in their
WWII fits is extremely limited), but the sources that I have give the
armament of two 45mm guns, two 37mm guns and two 20mm guns and three 12.7mm
DShK machine guns was carried from 1943 to 1944. I used kits two 37mm
guns. Two 45mm guns were not present in the kit, so I scratchbuilt two
of them using brass rod and gun shields made from Alps paper. 20mm
guns came from Tom's Modelworks set. 12.7mm guns came from modified
German 20mm guns from WEM set. The stern of the ship is extremely
cluttered with guns (eight guns of four different calibers in the space of
25 meters), so the only way for the 4" guns to fit was for them to be
elevated over each other and other guns, so I cut them just above the base
and re-glued them at elevated position. Three triple 18" torpedo
launchers were well cast but very plain with no surface detail, so I
detailed them with stretched sprue, which made them come alive. When
installing torpedo launchers be careful since Kombrig drawings show them all
facing backwards, but the photos that I have show the forward mount facing
backwards and aft mounts facing forward, so consult your references.
Masts Masts
presented a problem, since of the three photographs that I have of the ship
in WWII two don't show the aft mast and one that might (see the photo on
this page) but is of very bad quality and is hard to tell. Since I was
using that photo and Kombrig's plans showed it I decided to add it to my
model. The platforms on the forward mast in Kombrig's plans did not
correspond to the photo, so I went with the photo for my scratchbuilding.
Masts were scratchbuilt from brass rod and I used pantyhose threads for
rigging. I used a Soviet flag from Duane Fowler. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Weathering Once everything
was finished I weathered the ship with pastels and drybrushing. This
toned down the white stripes even more and made the ship look used.
However the available references show that Soviet ships didn't look very
weathered, so I kept the weathering toned down. After everything was
finished I sprayed the whole model with Model Master Dullcote to cover all
of the glue spots. After Dullcote dried I used Micro Kristal Klear to
glaze in the windows on the bridge and the illuminators in the hull as a
very last step. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Conclusion This
kit fills a big void in the kits of the Russian/Soviet destroyers and if you
are interested in either WWI or WWII Russian Destroyers I would recommend
this kit. Unfortunately if build as is, the proportions of the hull
would make the ship look subtly wrong, so I recommend you fix the hull
problems if you build the kit. The small details are well done, some
of the AA guns are missing but are easily replaced with PE aftermarket
products. Overall I would recommend this kit to any experienced
modeler who is interested in WWII DDs or Russian/Soviet ships. |
|
|
|
© ModelWarships.com |