This kit was produced by Custom Dioramics
in Canada and is now no longer in production. But I’ve a had a lot of people
wanting to know form be about this kit so I thought the best way would
be to do a review for Tim and Sean to put on the site for everyone to see.
The Box is nice and simplistic and shows a completed kit on the box
top and side built by Bob Russell. This is the only real colour guide in
the kit and it helps to give an indication of the final build assembly
but most who build this kit will prefer I have no doubt a nice camouflage
scheme rather than the 507B which it appears she’s been painted in the
picture. |
Contents include 42 resin parts in total. A 2-piece hull
for a waterline or full hull model is provided. 2 bags of resin parts including
boats, guns and davits are provided as well as a brass photo etch fret.
A nice touch is she also includes 2 wooden prop stands for the model to
sit on if being built full hull and she can then sit proud and raised from
a base. |
|
|
HULL PARTS |
|
Onto the kit itself the hull measures at waterline around
26.3cm long and the beam 2.6cm. The casting on my kit appears crisp and
clean for the lower part of the hull but there is flash right along the
edge for the full hull lower section. There are also a few small gaps and
this will need filling and sanding to get a good meet with the upper hull.
The top flat part of this lower section also seems to be finished in a
kind of glaze which at least makes it very flat and joins the upper hull
section flush, which has it also. |
Click images
to enlarge |
|
Moving onto the main kit part, the vessel herself, above
the waterline is cast in one part with the basic deckhouses, bridge and
funnels. Again all along the bottom edge it has large amounts of flash
and on my example a small bit missing at the bow. On a brighter note I
can see no visible signs of air bubbles and no signs of warpage in the
resin. The hull is devoid of surface detail apart from portholes.
Above decks the doors and portholes are represented well, but of course
would look better with a little photo-etch. I can also see the odd deck
hatch and capstan on the kit but other that that it is devoid of surface
detail, no visible signs of planking whatsoever. On the forecastle it shows
some extra surface detail that looks good ok. |
SUPERSTRUCTURE AND SMALL PARTS |
|
The smaller parts come in the kit in bags labelled 1 and
2 and are plagued with flash again. Though examining their general forms
they all seem acceptable if a little under detailed. Again 1/350 photo-etch
perhaps from WEM/GMM may of help here. The 5x 4” gun barrels provided would
again benefit from being replaced in the form of either small turned brass
or aluminium ones and the breach blocks scratch built. Also as well as
providing you an extra 4” gun barrel an extra 12pdr gun is also thrown
in for good measure. The 2 triple 21” torpedo tubes provided again they
seem basically sound but lack any kind of detail, super-detailing seems
the answer. |
|
|
|
PHOTO ETCH |
|
A brass photo-etch fret measuring 2 ½” by 8 ½”
with over 70 parts is a welcome addition and also 2 small brass rods for
the masts and some nice black anchor chain. The photo-etch fret also contains
spare parts for the modeller and for this kit it is equipped with railing,
ladders and propellers to name but a few of the goodies! |
|
|
INSTRUCTIONS |
|
The instructions are quite clear with step-by-step assemblies
shown and also a complete drawing and description of the kit parts. What
would have been nice would have been a colour chart showing examples of
camouflage schemes from different periods and different navies. Another
way the instructions would have better would have been some kind of rigging
plan and/or a diagram of a fully completed kit. |
The kit itself represents a V/W in their unmodified WW1 state. With a little
work any WW2 ship could be produced though if a ‘Wair’ AA escort was attempted
this would involve more work. A small piece of paper is included in the
box stating the kit was made from a set of David McGregor plans and an
address is provided to help you order them or to order other plans from
him. To my knowledge he’s no longer alive anymore and the new holder of
these plans is: -
Jean Chaplin,
C/o Great Britain Trust,
Great Western Dock,
Gas Ferry Road,
Bristol, BS1 6TY
I believe a full catalogue can be ordered if you right to the above,
they cover sailing ships and WW1 and WW2 vessels though I don’t own a catalogue
myself. |
|
|
Conclusions: |
|
Well that about sums up this kit. To my knowledge it is
the only 1/350 scale V/W class that has ever been produced. WSW did a 1/700
‘Wair’ WW2 ship but this unmodified by Armada Scale Models in 1/350 gives
the modeller the opportunity for lots of build options. To rate the kit
I’d give it 4 out of 5. The instructions could be better if they were as
good as say White Ensign Model’s. The resin quality isn’t as good as today’s
standards and the smaller resin parts though useful will be discarded by
most. The deck lacks relief detail or planking. On the positive the photo-etch
will provide added bits n bobs for the spares box as will the smaller resin
parts and we all know in 1/350 RN ships are not well catered from aftermarket
vendors. Overall though for a resin kit that is around 5 years old this
is a good place to start until anything more up-to-date emerges.
Thinking of the top of my head there was around 54 V/W class ships in
service in WW2. They served in the Royal, Royal Canadian and Royal Australian
Navies respectively and proved to be very rugged and touch little ships.
The very fact that many were still in active service in 1945 is testimony
to the skills of their WW1 builders such as Denny’s, William Beardmore,
John Brown, Cammell Laird and J. Samuel White’s to name just some of the
major ones.
On reflection I do hope you enjoyed this review and I’d like to say
I’d like to see many more of this class modelled; historically speaking
they were pressed into service and adapted into fleet destroyers; escort
and anti-aircraft roles all of which they were never intended for and this
was very much at a crucial timeframe of the war. In WW1 they were seen
as purely operating in the North Sea. In WW2 they were given the arduous
task, like most Destroyers of the Commonwealth Navies to being sued in
the Artic theatre, the Atlantic, the Channel, Coastal convoy duties, the
Mediterranean and the Far-East.
Happy modelling!
Laurence Batchelor |