Reviewed
August 2024
by Felix Bustelo |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
HISTORY | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
A number of European
countries underwent post-WW2 economic, humanitarian and military reconstruction.
Greece was one of those nations and the rebuilding of the Hellenic Navy
was greatly helped by American military aide and the transfer of surplus
ships. Among the ships that were transferred or sold to Greece were six
PGM motor gunboats in 1947. The PGM were PC-461 class patrol craft converted
from a primarily ASW ship to a gun boat with the addition of more 20mm
Oerlikons.
Based on photos found on Navsource.org, some of the ships remained essentially unchanged from their USN appearance through the 1960s. Later, on some of the ships, the forward 3-inch gun was replaced with a hedgehog launcher and aft twin 40mm Bofors with what it appears to be a single 40mm Bofors among some other minor modifications. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Hellenic Ship Model PGM-9 Class Gunboat | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Hellenic
Ship Model offers kits of Hellenic (Greek) Navy subjects in various scales.
All of the model kits are 3D printed and include both some older WW2 vintage
ex-USN ships that were sold or transferred to the Hellenic Navy as well
as modern vessels currently in service. I was intrigued by the selection
of ships and reached out to Kostas Kokkinos, the owner, about obtaining
some kits and he agreed to provide with a few samples to review on Modelwarships.com.
The
PGM-9 Class Gunboat is comprised of a 3D printed hull and smaller parts,
a base with pedestals, photoetch railings, one decal sheet and a paper
flag sheet. The contents come in a sturdy flip-top box, with the hull cushioned
inside bubble wrap and the 3D printed parts, PE and decals inside a zip-lock
bags. Assembly instructions are provided in the box as well as three small
pieces of sandpaper.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
HULL | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The 3D printed hull is very nicely done and sits on a printing raft with numerous thin attachment points at the end of the supports holding it to the raft. The hull has just about everything included on it, such as the bridge/forward superstructure, small housing aft, bases, tubs and splinter shields for the guns, hatches, lockers, chocks and mooring bitts, propeller guards along with some other deck details. PGMs measured 173 feet 8 inches long and in 1/350 scale, that would be approximately 5.9 inches. The kit hull measures just under 6 inches so it is spot on for scale. The print lines are barely there and should easily disappear under a coat of paint. Here and there, some thin “threads” appear along the deck and details that are a product of 3D printing and are to be removed. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SMALL 3D PRINTED PARTS | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
A
total of 10 print rafts with smaller parts are provided with the kit. All
of the rafts have thin attachment points that should make removing the
parts fairly easy but care must be taken with the more delicate items.
Some parts broke off during shipping and I think that the smaller part
rafts should be packed in plastic clamshell packets or something sturdier.
The
weapons come on four of the rafts. The first raft has the two 3-inch guns
and a single 40mm Bofors with separate barrels and mounts. The second raft
has eight single 20mm Oerlikons with tripod mounts. A third raft has the
hedgehog launcher along with a pair of watertight doors (one broke off),
Zodiac raft, radar and what appears to be a pelorus. The fourth raft has
a pair of roll off depth charge racks with separate sets of depth charges,
a pair of depth charge throwers with depth charges, a pair of davits and
the mast with radar dome.
A pair of identical rafts contain Carley floats in two sizes, alternate life raft cannisters for later fits, life rings, firehoses, mooring bumpers and either oxygen or acetylene tanks. Again, some of the parts broke off the rafts during shipping. Another pair of identical rafts contain boats, cable reels, anchors with attached chain, separate anchor chains, more handling davits, additional tanks, and what appear to be signal lamps. The last two rafts contain the running gear. One raft has pair of one-piece propeller shaft, propeller and rudders combinations. The other raft has a pair of rudders and propellers. I frankly do not know why the second raft. As mentioned above, a nice base with two pedestals that are also 3D printed are provided to display the full hull model if you so wish. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
PHOTO-ETCH | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
A
single small photoetch fret with the main deck railings is provided. The
railings have individual stanchion ends and not a bottom gutter. As you
may or may not know from my prior reviews, I am not a fan of railings with
individual stanchion ends as I find them a pain to cleanly glue to the
deck, but that is my personal taste and will be ok with other modelers.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
EXTRAS | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Three small strips
of sandpaper are included in the box. The grit of the sandpaper is not
written on the back of the strips but by touch, the darker strip is a tad
rougher than the other two which feel finer. These are an interesting addition
to a kit and while I don’t believe the print lines are so pronounced of
any of the parts that some sanding is needed, it is still a thoughtful
gesture.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
DECALS | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
One decal sheet
and a sheet of paper flags are provided. The decal sheet provides hull
numbers for the ships in Hellenic Navy service as well as their ensigns
and flags. The Hellenic Navy shield is also provided. Yellow Greek alphabet
ship names with hull numbers are also on the sheet and I assume that they
are meant to be used as a nameplate on the base included with the kit.
The paper sheet also has Hellenic Naval flags as well as set of signal
flags.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
INSTRUCTIONS | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The four-page
assembly instructions could honestly be better and are rather sparse in
my opinion. The first two pages contain a brief history in Greek along
with small photos taken from Navsource of the ships in Hellenic naval service.
The last two pages have several CAD renderings with a profile view and
some focused views which show the placement of some of the parts but not
all. Also, an attempt to show the placement of alternate parts, such where
the life raft cannisters replace the Carley floats, are provided. There
is no actual painting guide except for the profile view with no color references.
The profile view does show the placement of the hull number decals well
as the flags. A more complete set of illustrations would be been beneficial
to make assembly clearer. I also think that an inventory of the kit parts
should be included with the instructions and would be a great help to identify
the parts.
If you go to the Hellenic Ship Models website and view the page for this
model kit, there is several views of a nicely done built-up model depicting
a PGM in its original fit that was probably just after transfer in 1947.
I did notice that the build has a twin 40mm Bofors fitted aft but one is
not provided with the kit. Nonetheless, the photos do provide some help
in building one fit of the model. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CONCLUSIONS | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Overall,
this is a good kit and while I did point out some issues with the kit,
these are not insurmountable and should not deter someone from purchasing
this model. The hull is really well done as are most of the smaller parts.
You could even build a WW2 USN PGM using this kit by adding an aftermarket
twin 40mm Bofors. I would recommend this kit to someone who has experience
working with 3D printed kits with some delicate parts.
This kit is only available directly from Hellenic Ship Models, and this subject is also available in 1:144, 1:200 and 1:700 scales. My thanks to Kostas Kokkinos for providing the review sample. |