Text by Graham Holmes Photos by Martin J Quinn |
HISTORY | |||||||||||||||||||
The La Galissonnière-class
cruisers were designed and built commissioned by the French Navy in the
1930s. Principal characteristics were agreed by July 1931 based upon what
was effectively a prototype, Emile Bertin but with a protection system
based upon L’Algerie albeit lighter. All six ships were built in different
yards. The lead ship, La Galissonniere was commissioned in October 1936,
followed in order by Jean de Vienne, Marseillaise, Georges Leygues, Gloire
and Montcalm, in December 1937. They were considered fast, reliable and
successful light cruisers. Upon the outbreak of war all six were widely
deployed and heavily used. Much used from 1939 to 1940, three ships stayed
in Toulon and three moved to West Africa where Georges Leygues and Montcalm,
took part in the defence of Dakar. Whilst La Gloire was in Casablanca.
The other three, were kept under Vichy control at Toulon, and were scuttled
on 27 November 1942 with the rest of the fleet.
Georges Leygues, Montcalm and La Gloire joined the Allied forces after the successful Allied landings in North Africa in November 1942. Georges Leygues and Montcalm were refitted in Philadelphia and La Gloire in Brooklyn and accordingly the latter differed from the other two. After refitting, they took part in various Allied operations, including the Normandy landings in 1944. Postwar, several of the class acted as the flagship of the French Mediterranean Squadron and carried out operations off Indochina until 1954, and afterwards were deployed during the Suez Crisis and operations off Algeria. They were scrapped between 1958 and 1970. Above history as well as specifications and reference information, courtesy
of:
For more superficial information check out the Wikipedia page. |
|||||||||||||||||||
The
Trumpeter “French Light Cruiser Marseillaise” (Kit 05374)
Marseillaise is packaged in a typical Trumpeter sturdy box, with a painting of the subject on the lid of that looks like a photo of the real vessel on page 34 of reference A. Inside the box is the full hull in a segregated portion of the box together with the two piece deck, a bag with two PE sheets, a bag of decals and a bag of chain. The second section of the box has seven bags of sprues, containing ten plastic sprues and one clear sprue of the Loire 130M. The plastic is what we have some to expect of Trumpeter, light grey, sharply moulded, recessed scuttles with the attachment points mostly in convenient places. There is a filler piece of cardboard to take up unused space in the box, the length of which is defined by the hull. From comparison to the references, the kit depicts the subject as completed in 1937, as evidenced by the funnels caps that were changed in 1939. The only other kit in this scale of this subject is the Combrig Montcalm which I have in my collection, and I will compare the two where appropriate. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
THE HULL | |||||||||||||||||||
The hull is full hull and scales very
well to the measurements in ref A and matches the Combrig kit almost perfectly
in length, but there does seem to be a slight excess of the beam around
and abaft the bridge. The plans agree that it is a little beamy, not by
much but to the eye it looks worse than the measurements indicate, and
I think that is because it spoils the beautiful lines of the ship. Each
vessel in the class had a unique de-gaussing cable and the hull has none
of them included. Also, there are very noticeable longitudinal strakes
along the hull sides that are not represented, though fairly easy to reproduce,
so it should not be hard to add these.
Combrig includes them but compared to the pictures they are too proud in that kit. The scuttles seem pretty close to pictures, with the uneven spacing well represented. The holes for the Prop Guards look a little high compared to the waterline but I cannot measure it so I will give Trumpeter a break on that. The break from the foredeck to the aft is depicted as angled on the Trumpeter kit. This is correct for the original configuration of La Galissonniere, La Marseillaise, Montclam and Georges Leygues, but this was a vertical break with a round fillet at the bottom for Gloire and Jean de Vienne. Post update for all three ships it is just a vertical line. The lower hull shape is quite off, it seems to have been eating a little too much as it is quite bulbous and not at all like the plans that I have or the Combrig kit. There is additionally, a very strange set of indentation on the fillet at the stem. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
DECK (SPRUES M1 & M2) | |||||||||||||||||||
Next up is part M1.
This is the aft deck with the portion from the hangar giving a representation of planking. There are raised location parts for two deckhouse areas that are the correct size and shape as per Ref A. There is a locating place for the catapult and crane as well as the aft barbette. All in their correct locations. The vents and fittings are undersized, but the biggest miss is that the aircraft handling trolley tracks are completely absent. These are very prominent and a big miss. Also, Trumpeter appears to have repeated the error from the Belfast in that the representation of the planking extends too far forward, rather than stopping at the hangar. Next up is part M2. This is the forward deck as far aft as the front of the hangar. This includes all the usual deckhouses, recesses for forward superstructure, funnels, barbette and holes for anchor chain. Also represented are cradles for the ships boats and the layout does not match any of the vessels in Ref A for any of the time period for the life of these ships. This is not a big deal to change them, except that the number and size of the boats for the time period depicted are different. Trumpeter provide three 10m motorboats and two 10m dinghies. Ref A shows as built there should be two 9m motorboats, one 10m dinghy, one 9m dinghy and three 7m motorboats. I will let the builder decide whether to correct this. The forecastle area is a little plain, with no representation of the deck plating which is quite noticeable in photographs. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE A | |||||||||||||||||||
This sprue contains Turret #1 the two deck houses that fit between the main and shelter deck, props, prop shafts, prop guards, prop shaft supports, rudder, one motorboat and the forward breakwater. The prop guards are protected with foam, always a nice touch. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE B (X2) | |||||||||||||||||||
There are two of this sprue and they contain turret bases, 152mm gun barrels, 100mm turrets and their barrels, DCTs, anchors, 10m dinghies and various other small parts. Most of the parts are well represented but details are a little soft, but for most of the items on this sprue it isn’t as much of a drawback, and they are in line with other Trumpeter offerings. I will note that unlike their larger brethren the 100mm gun shields are good size and shape. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE C | |||||||||||||||||||
This has a number of important parts and is quite a mixed bag. The large bridge platform on the upper side is quite good and according to my references, a perfect size (Note, not all of the vessels had the same shape of this navigation bridge platform). However, the underside framing is wrong, but this will be hidden so not too much lost. Several other platforms are well sized and the starfish at the masthead is nice and delicate, in fact my copy was bent. The funnels are in the two pieces and well-shaped but again lacking in details. They have the vents but no horizontal ribbing, however, this may be a blessing as they would be lost in removing the seam. The funnel caps look good, but they are only applicable for the ship from as built through 1939. Shame there are not the post 1939 versions. Also on this sprue are the various pieces that make up the catapult, all in plastic! PE would have been so much better, at least for part C33. This sprue contains part C13 which is the solid part of the crane to which PE parts are added to make the full crane. This is the same as the two cranes for the hangar on the D sprue. Seems an overly complex way to make them. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE D (X2) | |||||||||||||||||||
There are two of this sprue and they contain motor launches, searchlights and handling cranes for the top of the hangar. Once again, they consist of a bland piece of plastic with two PE parts added on the side. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE F | |||||||||||||||||||
Sprue F this consists of four parts.
One part is the superstructure level with number 2 turret, and the next two levels of the bridge superstructure. Each of the parts are the correct shape but like most of the kit, the details if pretty spartan, with fairly featureless doors. The last part is the hangar, and this has problems. In addition to being a repeat of soft details, the deck house forward of the hangar is wrong for La Marseillaise. This shape depicted is right only for La Galissonniere and Jean de Vienne. The other four vessels had a deckhouse that was the full width of the hangar. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
SPRUE G1/G2/G3/G4/G5 | |||||||||||||||||||
These four sprues contain two parts,
(G1, G2) or one part only(G3-5). G1 & G2 are the
G1 is one of the forward superstructure level house.
I will address just the turrets in the G bag as well as the turret on Sprue A. Frankly these are pretty disappointing. Trumpeter have captured the fact that each turret is different especially turret 1 (Sprue A) having a different roof shape. But that is the only good. The detail is very soft, and the sharp edges are pretty rounded. Also, the turrets are too tall. At the front they are about 1.75mm too tall, but at the back they are about .02mm off, which naturally leads to the slope angle being wrong. Sigh. To add insult to injury, the length is about a 1mm too long. None of these dimensions are large, but it makes the shape look off and as there are so distinctively shaped turrets, it matters. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
LOIRE AIRCRAFT | |||||||||||||||||||
There are clear plastic parts for one Loire 130. Everyone has their opinion about plastic parts for the aircraft, but this looks pretty decent. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
PHOTOETCH | |||||||||||||||||||
PE A
This is a fairly basic PE set that includes some shorter lengths of both 2-bar and 3-bar railings, funnel cap grilles, inclined stairs, cranes, range clocks and a prop blade for the Loire 130. PE B
|
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
DISPLAY BASE OPTIONS | |||||||||||||||||||
This is a four piece stand to cradle the full build. Nothing of note. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
ANCHOR CHAIN | |||||||||||||||||||
The kit comes with an un-blackened anchor chain, in a small plastic bag. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
DECAL | |||||||||||||||||||
Decals are provided for the Loire 130, national flags, nameplates and the obligatory motivation plaques on French ships. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
INSTRUCTIONS | |||||||||||||||||||
The instructions are 12 pages, in booklet form, in the usual Trumpeter/HobbyBoss/I Love Kit format. | |||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||
CONCLUSIONS | |||||||||||||||||||
Over the years, ship modelers have been treated
by Trumpeter to a range of ship kits in plastic that we never dreamed possible.
This is another one that is really out of nowhere, though in my opinion
one of the most attractive warships ever built, and therefore much appreciated.
Out of the box, this will build up fairly easily as it is quite basic,
in fact too basic. Does it look like the subject, yes. But, to depict a
worthwhile replica of La Marseillaise as built would take some detailing,
either from an aftermarket set or some homemade detailing. Careful study
with the differences between the ships will be required but any of the
vessels from as built to 1941, can be made. This kit would benefit enormously
from 3D printed parts for new turrets, ships boats and general fittings
but those are limited for French subjects, alas. With a lot more work,
the rebuilt versions can be made but that is not within the scope of this
review.
This is Trumpeter's kit number 05374, the 1/350 French Cruiser Marseillaise. The model retails for $119.99, and is available from Squadron Models - who provided Modelwarships with a review sample - for $89.99.
|
|