Reviewed July 2021
by Matt Enochs
|
|
DESIGN
& HISTORY |
|
Design
The first American battleships designed after the Washington treaty
system began to break down in the mid-1930s, the South Dakotas were able
to take advantage of a treaty clause that allowed them to increase the
main battery to 16-inch (406 mm) guns. However, congressional refusal to
authorize larger battleships kept their displacement close to the Washington
limit of 35,000 long tons (36,000 t). A requirement to be armored against
the same caliber of guns as they carried, combined with the displacement
restriction, resulted in cramped ships. Overcrowding was exacerbated by
wartime modifications that considerably strengthened their anti-aircraft
batteries and significantly increased their crews.
A Brief History
USS South Dakota (BB-57) was the lead vessel of the four South Dakota-class
fast battleships built for the United States Navy in the 1930s. She was
made famous as “Battleship X” and for her AA performance at the Battle
of Santa Cruz.
South Dakota saw extensive action during World War II; immediately upon
entering service in mid-1942, she was sent to the south Pacific to reinforce
Allied forces waging the Guadalcanal campaign. The ship was damaged in
an accidental grounding on an uncharted reef, but after completing repairs
she returned to the front, taking part in the Battle of Santa Cruz in October
and the Second Naval Battle of Guadalcanal in November. During the latter
action, electrical failures hampered the ability of the ship to engage
Japanese warships and she became the target of numerous Japanese vessels,
sustaining over two-dozen hits that significantly damaged her superstructure
but did not seriously threaten her buoyancy. South Dakota returned to the
United States for repairs that lasted into 1943, after which she was briefly
deployed to strengthen the British Home Fleet, tasked with protecting convoys
to the Soviet Union.
In mid-1943, the ship was transferred back to the Pacific, where she
primarily operated with the fast carrier task force, contributing her heavy
anti-aircraft armament to its defense. In this capacity, she took part
in the Gilbert and Marshall Islands campaign in late 1943 and early 1944,
the Mariana and Palau Islands campaign in mid-1944, and the Philippines
campaign later that year. In 1945, she participated in the Battles of Iwo
Jima and Okinawa and bombarded Japan three times. Following the end of
the war in August 1945, she took part in the initial occupation of the
country before returning to the United States in September. She later moved
to the Philadelphia Naval Shipyard, where she was laid up in the Atlantic
Reserve Fleet until 1962, when she was sold for scrap |
|
|
The
Vee Hobby South Dakota
Vee
Hobby of China is a new player in the 1/700 Injected Plastic arena, their
initial offerings are the USS Missouri BB-63 and this kit the South Dakota
BB-57. They offer the subject kits in at least 3 editions, Basic, Deluxe
(subject of this review) and Platinum. Basic appears to be just Injected
with some minimal PE and the Platinum has everything in this box and more
including masks and additional PE. This kit like all kits of the South
Dakota portrays the ship after her 1943 repairs and upgrades, specifically
this kit is 6/1944 or as she was at the Battle of the Philippine Sea.
A lot of sprues and parts come in this box. The sprue breakdown is as follows
(There are no sprues E, F, H, I, K, L, O, Q, R, V, X, Y and Z): |
|
SPRUE
A - THE HULL |
|
Sprue
A is the Port and Starboard halves of the hull, this kit is waterline and
does not have an option for full hull. The hull sides have some very fine
hull plating molded in, a detail that can be contentious with some modelers
but not overdone and may even loose some due to painting.
|
|
SPRUE
B |
Sprue
B is the Deck and 5/38 mount barbettes. We get some very fine planking
effects molded in along with Bollards and Anchor Chain.
This
brings me to what I was afraid of after seeing the first renders for this
kit a year ago. Much like the classic Hasegawa kit, the bow is too narrow.
Here is my primitive photo-shopping skills, laid over the plans for the
Indiana. All details are in the right place, just the bow continues to
taper towards the stem instead of flaring out again. While some of this
is alleviated by the way the hull sides mate with the deck, it still lacks
that characteristic broad bow of this class. |
|
SPRUE
C |
|
Sprue
C Contains the Waterline Plate.
|
|
SPRUE
D |
|
Sprue
D Contains parts for the Forward Superstructure, Masts, Hull Braces and
Bulkheads. Detail is good with hatches and portholes being clearly defined.
We even see some very fine hand grabs on the upper superstructure.
|
|
SPRUE
G |
|
Sprue
G is a small fret that includes 40MM Bofor Tubs, MK51 Director Tubs and
other small Superstructure Parts.
|
|
SPRUE
J |
|
Sprue
J is another small fret, this one containing such parts as the Funnel Cap,
Breakwater and Masts.
|
|
SPRUE
M |
|
Sprue
M (x4) contains parts to build 2 of the 5/38 Guns. Detail is good and it
looks as if slide molding was used to capture access hatches and shell
ejection chutes.
|
|
SPRUE
N |
|
Sprue
N (x3) Contains a couple of styles of life rafts. Detail is good on these
considering their size.
|
|
SPRUE
P |
|
Sprue
P (x2) Contains the MK38 director, Aircraft crane and Catapults. Detail
is ok, but Catapult and Crane are molded solid so they will definitely
benefit from the PE upgrade.
|
|
SPRUE
S |
|
Sprue
S (x3) Contains the parts to build the “Teeth” of the battleship. Each
sprue has all the parts to construct the 16/45 triple turrets, slide molding
again was used as the muzzles of the barresl are hollow. The turret has
molded on ladders and rivets. There is a small amount of flash around the
barrels so again probably best replaced with brass ones. The Rangefinders
are a little bland, but seem to have the correct shape.
|
|
SPRUE
T |
|
Sprue
T (x3) Contains the AA guns. This I feel is major weak point for the kit.
The 20MM’s are molded as one piece and the attachment point is at the top
of the shield. There is no notch in the shield and the size of the attachment
will be difficult to remove cleanly. The 40MM Bofors are molded as 4 individual
parts but the molding seems soft, and the barrels are stuck together. There
have been much better examples in Injection Molding and the aftermarket
crowd will benefit from this
|
|
SPRUE
U |
|
Sprue
U Contains many of the smaller fittings such as boats, radars, paravanes,
Mk37 directors and searchlights. Detail is ok and the general shapes and
sizes look good. Radars again will benefit with a PE replacement.
|
|
SPRUE
W-1 |
|
Sprue
W1 is a 1-piece slide molded chunk of superstructure starting at the 04
level and incorporating the base of the funnel. It features nicely molded
hatches but the ladders and hand rails are very faint and will probably
be near invisible once painted.
|
|
SPRUE
W-2 |
|
Sprue
W2 is a slide molded conning tower. The number of vision slits seem to
match my photos of the real thing, though they seem a little soft. There
are also some vertical seams on the 4 corners, I don’t know if this was
an attempt at the rough casting texture seen on real conning towers or
an artifact of the molding process. They should be easy to clean up, just
seem odd.
|
|
SPRUE
W-3 |
|
Sprue
W3 is another Slide molded large part that starts with the 02 deck and
serves as the base for the superstructure. Here again we have some fine
porthole and hatch details, there are some unusual semicircular shapes
both Port and Starboard that I assume are meant to represent firehouse
reels? They will need to be replaced as they do not look right at all.
|
|
AIRCRAFT |
Sprue
OS2U (x2) sprue contains a 5 part OS2U Kingfisher as well as a 5 part SC-1
Seahawk. Detail is fine and with some careful assembly and cleanup, both
planes should play the part well. Canopies are molded on and solid.
|
|
PHOTO-ETCH |
|
The kit instructions
mention a small fret of PE, but it was not included in my kit, possibly
due to me purchasing the Deluxe Edition? |
|
DECALS |
|
The decal Sheet
includes Hull numbers, 4 styles of 2 types of flag as well as stars for
the float planes. The Box art alludes to an Alabama coming from Vee Hobby
and the Decals reinforce that with “60” Hull numbers as well as “59” so
it seems a Massachusetts is somewhere down the road. Sorry Indiana fans
does not look like one is planned, at least at this time |
|
|
|
DELUXE
EDITION EXTRAS |
|
WOOD
DECK |
|
The Deluxe edition
includes a stained blue wooden deck. I actually like this one as it’s not
as “Clean” as some stained decks I have seen. There is a little bit of
the wood color bleeding through in some spots giving it the worn look of
a deck in the middle of the action in the Pacific. |
|
|
|
RESIN
& BRASS |
|
It also includes
some small bags with Brass barrels for the 16-inch guns, 5/38’s, anchor
chain, turned brass masts and resin Blast Bags. The brass barrels and masts
look very nice and will greatly enhance the base kit |
|
|
|
DELUXE
EDITION PHOTO-ETCH |
|
You also get 3 sheets
of relief etched PE. These parts will greatly enhance some of the softer
spots in the plastic molding. Sheet A contains the Catapults,
Aircraft Crane, SK Radar, Various Mast details, Floater net baskets, MK12
and MK22 radars.
Sheet B contains Railings, ladders, Anchor tread
plate and boat details.
Sheet C contains 20MM guns & shields, 40MM
rails & shields and superstructure details. |
|
|
|
INSTRUCTIONS |
|
The
base kit includes a *Large* 2 sided sheet of instructions. Reminiscent
of the old Tamiya or Hasegawa instructions sheets, but on steroids. Assemblies
are clear and easy to read and sequence seems logical. The base kit
also includes a paint chart. The official Navy designation
is called out and it is cross referenced to a brand of paint along with
mixes. Guessing Mr. Color but I may be wrong. It is interesting that they
have colors like 5-D on there possibly alluding to some 1941 era kits in
the future.
The Deluxe Instructions are a double-sided sheet with color pictures.
The are also clear and will help in placement of the enhanced PE. |
|
CONCLUSIONS |
|
Is
the Vee Hobby USS South Dakota the new Flyhawk level of this famous battleship?
No, however it is light years ahead of the old Hasegawa edition and with
the PE of the Deluxe and/or Platinum editions should give the Trumpeter
kit a run for its money. With exception of the small AA, the base kit looks
like it will build into a nice model and with some effort and AM it could
be a beautiful rendition of “Battleship X”.
Although
I am eager for new subjects in Injection Plastic, I understand the importance
of supporting a newcomer. If Vee Hobby takes reviews like this to heart,
they have an opportunity to improve and be a good contender with some hopefully
new and untapped kit subjects in the future. On a scale of 1-10 with 10
being best, I would give this kit a 7 ½. There are some things that
could be better, but with exception of the bow shape, the kit shows good
attention to being accurate and a good base for upgrading to the modelers
taste.
I
purchased this kit for $65 off of eBay. |
|